Commercial
Appeal Articles on the Death of Rosmari Pleasure
SUSPECT
SURRENDERS IN SHOOTING DEATH OF MIDTOWN WOMAN - WEDNESDAY,
March 4, 1998
EX-BOYFRIEND
HELD, FACES CHARGE OF MURDERING MIDTOWN WOMAN - THURSDAY, March
5, 1998
PASTOR
SEES GOD'S LOVE THROUGH HIS OWN PAIN - SUNDAY, March 15, 1998
SCHOLARSHIP
FUND OPENS IN MEMORY OF PLEASURE - TUESDAY, April 14, 1998
FRIEND'S
DEATH BY VIOLENCE INSPIRES RUN FOR LIFE 5K TO FUND RETREAT AT
HER CHURCH AND SCHOLARSHIPS - MONDAY, October 19, 1998
EX-BOYFRIEND
GUILTY OF MURDERING MIDTOWN WOMAN, GETS 51 YEARS - FRIDAY, March
3, 2000
SUSPECT
SURRENDERS IN SHOOTING DEATH OF MIDTOWN WOMAN
Date - WEDNESDAY, March 4, 1998
Section: News
Page: A10
Memo: obituary
Edition: Final
A suspect in the shooting death of an editorial
assistant at The Commercial Appeal turned himself in to police
late Tuesday night.
The suspect in Monday's shooting of Rosmari Pleasure,
34, had not been charged.
Pleasure was shot and killed Monday afternoon outside
her apartment building at 203 Hawthorne. Police Insp. R. G. Wright
said Pleasure apparently knew her attacker.
Services for Pleasure will be at 11 a.m. Saturday
at Springdale Baptist Church. She will be buried at New Park Cemetery.
N. J. Ford and Sons Funeral Home has charge.
She is survived by her father, Rev. Mose Pleasure
of Memphis, former Tennessee Department of Human Services commissioner;
a stepmother, Jo Sutton Pleasure of Memphis; sisters Billi J.
Rucker of Atlanta and Perci A. Simpson of Louisville, Ky.; brothers
Mose Pleasure III of Dallas, Robert William David Pleasure of
Memphis and Derek A. Dallas of Atlanta; grandmothers Lavenia Parker
of Birmingham, Celestine J. Pleasure of Gilford, Conn., and Willie
M. Sutton of Louisville, and a grandfather, William Parker of
Birmingham. She was preceded in death by her mother, Bernice Pleasure.
A scholarship is being set up at the University
of Memphis in her name.
All content herein is © 1998 THE COMMERCIAL APPEAL
and may not be republished without permission.
Top
EX-BOYFRIEND
HELD, FACES CHARGE OF MURDERING MIDTOWN WOMAN
Date: THURSDAY, March 5, 1998
Section: Metro
Page: B2
Illustration: photo
Source: By Chris Conley The Commercial Appeal
Edition: Final
The 30-year-old ex-boyfriend of an editorial assistant
at The Commercial Appeal was charged Wednesday in her shooting
death.
Vincent Hatch, a University of Memphis student,
was charged with first-degree murder for twice shooting Rosmari
Pleasure, fatally wounding her. He was being held without bond
Wednesday at the Criminal Justice Center.
About noon Monday, Hatch went to Pleasure's home
at 203 Hawthorne and parked his gray Volkswagen Jetta in the rear
parking lot and waited until Pleasure came home for lunch, according
to an affidavit filed in the case.
About 12:25 p.m., Pleasure arrived. Hatch got out
of his car, gun in hand, and ran toward Pleasure. She screamed
when she saw him.
Pleasure called to a neighbor that Hatch had a gun
and asked the neighbor to call police. When the neighbor, Ashley
Oates, turned to reach a telephone, she heard a shot. She looked
out her window and saw Hatch standing over Pleasure, who was lying
on the ground. Oates then saw Hatch shoot a second time.
Pleasure was shot once in the knee and once in the
back of the head, the affidavit says.
Hatch, who immediately became a suspect after the
shooting, notified homicide detectives through his grandmother
on Tuesday that he wanted to surrender. He was arrested at the
grandmother's house at 337 Essex shortly after 4 p.m. and questioned.
Police have said the shooting was the result of
a domestic dispute.
Pleasure was active in the Evergreen Historic District
Association and recently became the first non-homeowner elected
to its board.
She was the daughter of Rev. Mose Pleasure, a former
commissioner of the state Department of Human Services.
Pleasure said his last day with his daughter, which
was Sunday, began with services at Antioch Baptist Church in Whiteville
and ended with a family dinner that evening. Mose Pleasure is
the associate minister at the church.
Mose Pleasure and the public relations firm Harvest
Reapers Communications opened a journalism scholarship fund Wednesday
at the NBC bank branch, 2632 Frayser Blvd. The goal is to establish
a scholarship at the University of Memphis, which Pleasure attended.
The bank branch in Frayser is accepting donations
to the fund. Regina Burns of Harvest Reapers said arrangements
are being made for all NBC branches to accept donations by this
weekend. Harvest Reapers has more information on the fund at 332-8616.
To reach reporter Chris Conley, call 529-2595 or
E-mail conley@gomemphis.com Vincent Hatch.
All content herein is © 1998 THE COMMERCIAL APPEAL
and may not be republished without permission.
Top
PASTOR
SEES GOD'S LOVE THROUGH HIS OWN PAIN
Date: SUNDAY, March 15, 1998
Section: Metro
Page: B1
Source: David Waters
Memo: Faith Matters
Edition: Final
It was chilly that Sunday morning, so Rosmari sat
in the sunshine in her father's church. The seat warmed body and
soul. She sang. And she prayed.
She was so joyful.
The next day, her father, Rev. Mose Pleasure, stood
in the shadows of the morgue and identified her body. He felt
so cold. He cried. And he prayed.
He was so angry.
If anyone has a right to be angry with God, Mose
Pleasure does.
In 1968, his close friend and mentor, Dr. Martin
Luther King Jr., a man of God, was murdered in Memphis.
In 1985, Rosmari's mother Bernice, a schoolteacher
and faithful churchgoer, was abducted from her Memphis home, raped
and murdered.
On March 2, his 34-year-old daughter, a prayerful
and devoted Christian herself, was shot and killed outside her
Midtown apartment. Police have charged an ex-boyfriend.
Rosmari Pleasure liked for people to call her ``Roz.''
Her father called her Rose. She was his gift from God.
He baptized his daughter when she was 10. She loved
to pray, even as a child.
``I would say, `Baby, let's pray,' and it was as
if I was serving dinner,'' he said.
Rosmari was sustained by prayer, nurtured by worship.
She lived to go to church and invited everyone to go with her.
She was always aware of God's presence. Her father
says that's why she was so trusting, the most trusting person
he's ever known.
``Rose was all empathy,'' he said. ``She always
looked for the God-ness in people.''
Rosmari's faith held even after her mother was murdered,
Pleasure said. She wanted to know who did it, and why. She never
questioned God or doubted her faith.
He won't start now.
``God gives us free will,'' Pleasure said. ``The
tangled web of choices we all make leads us to intersections in
life where good or ill can happen.
``That man's life path led him to that point. Rose's
path intersected with his. What happened was not God-directed.
``Rose's life was a statement of faith, not her
death.''
To Mose Pleasure, faith is a way of seeing. Because
of Rosmari's faith, she saw life and death with spiritual eyes.
Her eyes allowed her to see wonder amid horror, joy amid sorrow,
God's gifts amid the world's garbage.
Rosmari had her father's eyes.
The day before she died, her father preached in
two churches. She went with him to both. They rode together, worshiped
together, ate lunch and dinner together.
That afternoon, on the way back to Memphis, she
told her father about the house she was going to buy in two years.
That evening, she joked and laughed and ate catfish
smothered in hot sauce.
``We were together for 12 1/2 hours Sunday,'' he
said.
``It was 12 1/2 hours of intensive, joyous togetherness.
It wasn't until Tuesday that I realized we had never spent that
much time alone together in one day in her entire life. ``I didn't
realize what a gift Sunday was until Tuesday.''
Sunday she spent with her father.
Monday, she died and a part of him died with her.
Tuesday, Rosmari was resurrected in his heart. Now,
through Mose Pleasure's spiritual eyes, he sees his Rose sitting
joyously in the sunshine, not lying lifeless in the shadows.
The sight warms his soul. To reach reporter David
Waters, call 529-2399 or E-mail waters@gomemphis.com.
All content herein is © 1998 THE COMMERCIAL APPEAL
and may not be republished without permission.
Top
SCHOLARSHIP
FUND OPENS IN MEMORY OF PLEASURE
Date: TUESDAY, April 14, 1998
Section: Metro
Page: B2
Source: John Semien
Memo: METRO & MID-SOUTH BRIEFS
Edition: Final
The father of Rosmari Pleasure, an editorial assistant
at The Commercial Appeal who was shot to death on March 2, has
started a journalism scholarship fund in her memory at the University
of Memphis.
Rev. Mose Pleasure Jr. started the Rosmari Pleasure
Memorial Scholarship Fund at National Bank of Commerce. It has
climbed to more than $1,000 through donations.
Eventually the fund will be used for scholarships
at the university, where Rosmari Pleasure studied. Tax-deductible
contributions may be made at any NBC branch.
For more information, contact Harvest Reapers Communications
at 332-8616.
All content herein is © 1998 THE COMMERCIAL APPEAL
and may not be republished without permission.
Top
FRIEND'S
DEATH BY VIOLENCE INSPIRES RUN FOR LIFE 5K TO FUND RETREAT
AT HER CHURCH AND SCHOLARSHIPS
Date: MONDAY, October 19, 1998
Section: Metro
Page: B1
Illustration: photo
Source: By Jacinthia Jones The Commercial Appeal
Memo: See Information Box at end of text
Edition: Final
As Rosalyn Nichols attended the funeral of a third
childhood friend - another victim of what she calls `relational
violence' - she thought to herself, ``What can I do to prevent
this from happening again?''
"It bothered me," said Rev. Nichols. "I
didn't want this to be just another case where we grieve and go
on. I guess having experienced it two other times, it said to
me that the only way you're here is by grace." That was in
March.
A few months later, Nichols came up with the idea
of "Sisters 4 Life," a small group of women united after
the loss of their friend, Rosmari Pleasure.
Police said Pleasure, 34, was shot and killed outside
her Midtown apartment by ex-boyfriend Vincent Hatch on March 2.
He is charged with first-degree murder. She was an editorial assistant
for The Commercial Appeal.
On Nov. 14, Sisters 4 Life will host the Rosmari
Pleasure Memorial 5K Walk/Run at Handy Park on Beale. It's designed
as a way to bring attention to violence, specifically relational
violence as Nichols defines it.
"It's not just about domestic violence between
a husband and wife," says Nichols, who grew up with Pleasure
at Metropolitan Baptist Church. "There's violence between
people with all kinds of relationships."
More than 400 misdemeanor and felony arrests for
domestic violence are made in Shelby County each month, according
to the county government Victim's Assistance Office. And domestic
violence counselors estimate that only 1 in 10 cases is ever reported.
For the sisters, the 5K run is a way to start a
dialog about a problem that stretches across all social and economic
backgrounds.
"In a larger sense, it's about the community
coming together to celebrate life itself and (to show) what we
lose when these types of acts of violence are allowed to persist,"
Nichols said. "It's not exclusive to women because it's as
much about the men that we lose because of these acts.
"It's kind of like family taking care of itself,
trying to stop a silent but pervasive problem in our community."
"In the African-American community we especially
seem to be so hush-hush about (domestic) violence," said
Judy Davis. "We refuse to talk about it."
Davis also grew up in the church with Pleasure and
later roomed with her at the University of Tennessee, Knoxville.
After the run, the group, based at Metropolitan
Baptist, plans to become involved in other women's issues, such
as health and finance. The group is not exclusive to church members.
Proceeds from the run will go toward the women's
retreat at the church in February and the Rosmari Pleasure Memorial
Scholarship Fund, established earlier this year for journalism
students at the University of Memphis.
Memphis native and Olympic track star Rochelle Stevens
has agreed to be the host runner during the race. The group also
has garnered corporate sponsorships from Nike, Buns On the Run,
Backyard Express, AutoZone, American Healthcare Inc., Sales and
Marketing Concepts and Kraft Foods. They are looking for volunteers
as well as other sponsors.
Explaining the group's sponsorship efforts, Nichols
said, "We called, we rattled some phones, we begged. Rose's
life affected so many that when we tell people this story, they
automatically know, they remember and they want to do something."
For more information on the 5K Run, contact Rev.
Nichols at 948-3179. Entry fees are $15 for runners and $10 for
walkers and are available the day of the race.
INFORMATION BOX: Staff
Trouble ahead
Domestic violence experts have compiled a list of
behavioral signs that are often exhibited in men who have the
potential to become violent. The more signs, the stronger the
chances for violence. In some cases, only a couple of signs may
be exhibited in a very exaggerated manner, such as extreme jealousy.
1. Jealousy
2. Controlling behavior
3. Quick involvement or whirlwind courtships
4. Unrealistic expectations
5. Forces isolation from friends and family
6. Blames others for problems
7. Blames others for feelings
8. Hypersensitivity or feelings hurt easily
9. Cruelty to animals or children
10. Playful use of force in sex
11. Verbal abuse
12. Rigid gender roles
13. Sudden mood changes
14. Past instances of battering
15. Threats of violence
16. Breaking, beating, throwing objects
17. Any force during arguments, including restraining
person from leaving
Source: Project for Victims of Family Violence,
Inc., Fayetteville, Ark.; Center for Battered Women, Austin, Texas
To reach reporter Jacinthia Jones, call 529-2780
or E-mail jjones@gomemphis.com
Caption: By Kent Phillips (Color) A sign on the
counter at Fino's on Madison asks for contributions to the Rosmari
Pleasure scholarship fund. Pleasure was killed in March and a
former boyfriend is charged.
All content herein is © 1998 THE COMMERCIAL APPEAL
and may not be republished without permission.
Top
EX-BOYFRIEND GUILTY OF MURDERING
MIDTOWN WOMAN, GETS 51 YEARS
Date: FRIDAY, March 3, 2000
Section: Metro
Page: B1
Illustration: photo (2)
Source: By Lawrence Buser The Commercial Appeal
Edition: Final
A jury Thursday took just 30 minutes to convict
the ex-boyfriend of an editorial assistant at The Commercial Appeal
of first-degree murder, rejecting his claims of momentary insanity.
Vincent L. Hatch, 32, was automatically sentenced
to life in prison, a minimum of 51 years, for the execution-style
shooting of Rosmari Pleasure, who was killed in her Midtown driveway
two years ago.
Prosecutors called it "a cowardly and cold-blooded
murder.'' Hatch, who represented himself, said he was "not
in my right mind'' that day and asked for an acquittal.
Pleasure, 34, was killed shortly after noon March
2, 1998, outside her apartment at 203 Hawthorne, where she had
gone for lunch. Hatch was waiting for her as she got out of her
car. She screamed to a neighbor that he had a gun and to call
police.
"Rosmari was crouched down and Vincent Hatch
looked up at me and said kind of sarcastically `Yeah, you better
call police,' '' said Ashley Oates, who knew them both. "I
started to call police and then heard a shot. I looked out the
window and he was standing over her and then I saw him shoot her
again with two hands on the gun.''
Pleasure was shot in the knee and in the back of
the head and had injuries to her face that indicated she may have
been pistol-whipped, medical examiner Dr. O. C. Smith testified.
Hatch, who was living in a dorm at the University
of Memphis, where he was a student, was arrested the next day
in South Memphis. He gave police a three-page confession. In the
two-day trial before Criminal Court Judge John Colton Jr., Hatch
blamed his behavior on mental and emotional problems brought on
by family difficulties and a troubled childhood.
"Just look at me as a person with genuine problems,''
Hatch pleaded with jurors Thursday, adding that he was prone to
crying spells and had attempted suicide in jail. "I would
never hurt her in my right mind.''
Prosecutors James Wax Jr. and Scott Gordon noted
that a psychologist found Hatch to have personality problems but
no serious mental illness that would keep him from knowing right
from wrong.
"He won't take no for an answer, that's his
problem,'' Gordon argued, urging jurors to reject Hatch's claims.
" `Dr. Hatch' knows more than the psychologists. `I'm insane.
Take my word for it.' This is a license to kill that he's asking
for.''
Pleasure was the daughter of Mose Pleasure, a former
commissioner of the state Department of Human Services and associate
pastor at Antioch Baptist Church in Whiteville.
In 1985, her mother, Bernice Pleasure, a teacher,
was abducted from her Memphis home and murdered.
To reach reporter Lawrence Buser, call 529-2385
or E-mail buser@gomemphis.com
Caption: Vincent Hatch, Rosmari Pleasure
All content herein is © 2000 THE COMMERCIAL APPEAL
and may not be republished without permission.
Top
|